If you’ve spent some time in Roblox The Forge, you’ve probably noticed that weapon damage isn’t always as straightforward as it looks on the crafting menu. Players often ask questions like: Why does my damage feel different even with higher stats? or Why does one weapon outperform another even when their numbers look close? In this guide, I’ll break down the common questions players have about weapon damage and give clear answers based on in-game testing and practical experience.

What Affects Weapon Damage the Most in The Forge?

The first thing many players wonder is: What actually determines my damage output?

The answer is a mix of base weapon stats, material quality, rune bonuses, and your attack timing. Base stats give you the foundation, but they’re only part of the picture. Higher-tier ore or rare materials add extra multipliers, and the quality roll you get during forging makes a surprisingly huge difference.

One thing I’ve learned after dozens of craft attempts is that even small stat bumps matter, especially when stacking crit bonuses. If you ever plan to optimize early builds, getting stronger materials makes the biggest difference because they push both base damage and scaling.

And by the way, if you ever experiment with different crafted setups, Roblox players often compare builds in community discussions that also talk about whether they should buy The Forge items to accelerate progression. It’s not required, but it does help you test more weapon variations quickly.

Why Do Two Weapons With Similar Stats Deal Different Damage?

This is one of the most common questions: If two weapons show nearly identical numbers, why does one hit harder?

The secret is hidden multipliers and attack type behavior. Some weapons swing faster but have lower per-hit damage, while others strike slower but land heavier hits. The game doesn’t always show exact attack speed on the crafting menu, so it’s easy to underestimate it.

Fast weapons are amazing for triggering combo bonuses and rune effects. Heavy weapons, on the other hand, shine when you can land clean, full-charge attacks. This is where your playstyle comes in. If you’re quick at positioning, heavy axes and hammers can outperform mid-tier blades by a lot.

I remember testing two rare swords with almost identical damage stats, yet one still outperformed the other simply because its swing arc hit multiple targets more consistently. Sometimes the “feel” of a weapon matters just as much as its numbers on paper.

How Much Do Runes Actually Increase DPS?

Players often ask: Are runes really worth the effort?

Absolutely. Runes are one of the biggest damage boosters in the entire game, especially once you unlock more advanced slots. Even a single high-tier damage rune can push your DPS far beyond what raw weapon stats can achieve.

Damage runes, crit rate runes, and attack speed runes all affect output differently. For example:

Attack speed runes give more consistent overall damage.

Crit rate runes shine when paired with weapons that already have high crit multipliers.

Elemental runes become great in late-game regions where enemies have specific weaknesses.

Rune synergy is also where some players experiment with gear they got from community trades or by looking for ways to buy The Forge items cheap to test multiple builds. The point isn't the purchase itself, but that having more gear variations helps you understand how different rune combos behave.

Does Material Quality Change Damage, or Just Durability?

A common question is: Do higher-quality materials only affect durability?

No. Quality matters for both durability and damage scaling. When you forge with higher-quality ore, the base damage and the scaling stats improve noticeably. That’s why late-game materials feel like a massive upgrade rather than a mild improvement.

If you’re struggling with mobs in mid-game regions, upgrading your materials often gives a bigger power spike than changing weapons entirely. I learned this the hard way when I spent too much time crafting new weapon types instead of just enhancing the ones I already liked.

Do Attack Animations Influence Real Damage Output?

Another question players ask is: Does animation length really affect DPS?

Yes. Faster animations can feel smoother and offer better DPS over time. Slow, heavy weapons deal more per hit but require cleaner timing. Animation canceling also plays a role, especially when dodging mid-swing to avoid damage.

This is why some weapon classes "feel" stronger even without the highest numbers. For instance, broadswords often outperform heavy axes during early progression simply because you stay mobile while attacking.

If you enjoy theorycrafting, U4GM community discussions sometimes test these numbers and compare findings. Their breakdowns can be helpful, especially if you're trying to figure out why a certain weapon feels stronger than expected.

Which Weapon Type Provides the Best Damage in Different Stages?

Players frequently ask: What’s the best damage weapon early, mid, and late game?

While the exact meta shifts with updates, general trends stay consistent:

Early game:

One-handed swords for fast, reliable hits.

Light hammers for easy crit chains.

Mid game:

Dual weapons for stacking rune effects.

Broadswords for great balance and strong scaling.

Late game:

Heavy weapons once you have the runes, stats, and timing to support them.

Elemental-focused weapons in zones where mobs have specific weaknesses.

Remember that damage is not only about the weapon type, but how it interacts with your runes, materials, and timing.

Is It Worth Testing Multiple Builds to Find the Best Damage Setup?

The final question many players ask is: Should I stick to one build or experiment with many?

Testing different builds can be surprisingly helpful. Each weapon type has its own rhythm, and what feels strong to one player might feel awkward to another. The most effective approach is to pick one or two weapon types you enjoy and refine them through crafting, runes, and material upgrades.

You don’t have to rush the process. Experimenting at your own pace makes the game more fun, and you’ll naturally discover which damage patterns fit your playstyle best.

Balance Changes Overview: Roblox The Forge Guitar Location: How to Find Bard's Lost Guitar